Best Type of Hay for Guinea Pigs (First Cut, Second Cut, Timothy…?)

Daisy and Peach posing beside a mini bale of first cut timothy hay.

Hay is an essential part of your guinea pig’s diet. In fact, hay should consist of 80% of your guinea pig’s daily food intake.

Hay is necessary to keep your guinea pig’s digestive tract moving, prevent GI stasis, and keep their ever-growing teeth worn down.

However, there are so many different types of hay to choose from! Is all hay safe for guinea pigs? Which types are actually best to feed guinea pigs?

Should you get first cut, second cut, or third cut hay? And is it safe to buy bales of horse hay for your guinea pig? I’ll touch on all these topics throughout the article.

Types of Hay That Are Best for Guinea Pigs

First or second cut timothy hay is generally accepted as the best hay for guinea pigs. Orchard hay comes in at a close second.

Other types of hay, such as meadow hay, bluegrass, brome, bermuda grass, and oat hay are also safe for guinea pigs.

However, some of these are best fed occasionally or mixed with other hays. I’ll go into more detail on this below.

TJ; the king of the hay castle.

Timothy Hay for Guinea Pigs

Timothy hay is the most common hay for guinea pigs.

Timothy hay is the most commonly recommended hay for guinea pigs. It’s low in calcium, nutrient-rich, and suitable for guinea pigs of all ages. 

Timothy hay is a good choice to free feed your guinea pig on a daily basis.

Psst! Find 10 more foods you can feed your guinea pig daily here!

Timothy hay is widely available and typically easy to find. Most guinea pigs love the smell and taste of this hay as well.

Is Western Timothy Hay the Same as Timothy Hay?

Yes, Oxbow’s Western Timothy hay is the same as regular timothy hay. Oxbow’s brand of Western timothy hay is one of the most popular types of hay for small animals.

Orchard Grass Hay for Guinea Pigs

Orchard grass hay is another great alternative to timothy hay. Orchard hay is suitable for guinea pigs young and old and can be free fed on a daily basis. Like timothy, orchard hay is nutrient-rich and low in calcium. Orchard grass is often softer than timothy, so it may encourage fussy guinea pigs to eat more hay.

Orchard hay is often a better option for people with allergies too. If you think you’re allergic to your guinea pigs, try switching their hay! Oftentimes allergies are caused by the hay rather than the guinea pigs themselves.

Meadow Hay for Guinea Pigs

Meadow hay is another suitable choice to feed your guinea pigs. Meadow hay consists of long strands of grass hay, along with various other plants, flowers, leaves, seed heads, and stems that grow alongside the hay in the meadow. Guinea pigs that love foraging and variety often love meadow hay.

Can Guinea Pigs Eat Alfalfa Hay?

Alfalfa hay has a higher calcium content than other types of hay. For this reason, it should only be fed to guinea pigs under 6 months, or to pregnant/nursing moms that can use the extra calcium. If adult guinea pigs have too much calcium in their diet, they can develop bladder stones, which may require surgery to remove.

Young guinea pigs need extra calcium for proper growth, but they can get it from a variety of different sources. Pellets that are made for young guinea pigs usually have all the calcium they need for proper growth and development.

If you’re housing a baby guinea pig with adults, your best option is to feed the baby some calcium-rich vegetables separately from the older guinea pigs. That way, you don’t have to worry about the adults getting too much excess calcium in their diet from baby pellets or alfalfa hay.

Can Guinea Pigs Eat Bermuda Hay?

Bermuda hay is a good, albeit less common, hay choice for guinea pigs. Bermuda hay is nutritious for guinea pigs, with a high fiber content. However, it is slightly higher in calcium than timothy and orchard grass hay. Therefore, it may not be a good choice for guinea pigs that are prone to bladder stones.

It can be good to mix in with other hays for more variety. If you feed this hay exclusively, keep an eye out for white pee spots in your guinea pig’s cage. If you see these, it means your guinea pig has too much calcium in their diet and you may want to switch to some lower-calcium foods.

Can Guinea Pigs Eat Brome Hay?

Yes, guinea pigs can eat brome hay on a regular basis. Brome hay is a popular type of horse hay. It has low calcium and a similar nutritional value to other grass hays.

However, many guinea pigs don’t like the taste of brome hay and therefore might not eat enough hay for a balanced diet. If you find that your guinea pigs aren’t eating it very much, you may have to switch to a different type of hay.

Bluegrass Hay for Guinea Pigs

Bluegrass is a good type of hay to feed your guinea pigs daily. Bluegrass is a soft, green hay. Most guinea pigs love the taste and texture of it. It is similar in nutritional content to other grass hays on this list.

Similar to orchard hay, bluegrass is a less dusty, allergy-friendly hay. If you’re struggling with allergies, switching to this hay could be worth a try.

Oat Hay for Guinea Pigs

Oat hay is another common type of hay you can feed your guinea pigs. Oat hay is fine for guinea pigs of all ages, but it does tend to be higher in calories than other hays. Also, because it is grain hay, it’s a bit harder for guinea pigs to digest.

Because of this, it’s best fed as a treat or combined with other hays. It can be good to feed this hay to underweight or senior guinea pigs that struggle to keep weight on. If your guinea pigs are on the chunky side, oat hay is best avoided, or mixed in occasionally with their regular hay as a treat.

Should You Feed Your Guinea Pig Hay Cubes?

Any kind of horse hay cubes or compressed hay, such as Oxbow Hay Stacks should be given as a treat or chew toy rather than your guinea pig’s main supply of hay.

Hay should be frely available in loose piles at all times for your guinea pig. Not eating enough hay can result in digestive and teeth problems, so you should make it as easy as possible for your guinea pigs to eat the hay that they need.

If you’re offering horse hay cubes to your guinea pig as a treat, be sure to choose cubes without alfalfa in them. Many hay cubes for horses are mixed with alfalfa.

A good alternative would be to purchase 100% timothy hay cubes made for guinea pigs or try out Oxbow’s compressed hay stacks.

Skylar loves Oxbow hay stacks. They are an excellent chew toy and source of enrichment.

What is the Difference Between First, Second, and Third Cut Hay for Guinea Pigs?

If you ever buy hay by the bale from a farmer, you’ll notice that the hay is usually sold as either first, second, or third cut hay. The cut refers to when the hay was harvested. First cut is the first cutting of hay of the season, second is the second cutting, etc.

The main difference between these types is the coarseness. First cut will consist of harder, thicker strands of hay. It usually contains more seed heads, which guinea pigs love.

Second cut hay is softer and may entice fussy eaters more than first cut. Third cut hay has a very fine and soft texture, almost like grass.

First cut hay is often a bit cheaper than second cut and it does the best job of wearing down your guinea pig’s evergrowing molars. However, some guinea pigs don’t like it as much and may waste more of it.

Pet store hay sold in bags for guinea pigs is usually first cut hay. First cut is great for guinea pigs if you can find a good quality supplier. Look for hay that is fresh smelling and harvested this season or last.

Second cut hay is softer and piggies usually love it. This type of hay is great for all guinea pigs, but especially those that are underweight or not big on eating hay.

Second cut hay was my first choice for many years. However, after having two guinea pigs with teeth issues, I personally have switched over to first cut for the foreseeable future.

It’s hard to say whether the hay had any influence, as both pigs were 6 years old. All my other piggies were fine, and have been eating the second cut hay for many years, so it may be pure coincidence.

However, I wanted to make a change to see if there was any correlation between the type of hay. I won’t know anything for at least a couple of years, but I will update this if teeth issues continue on the first cut hay.

Third cut hay is less common than the first two, as there isn’t always a third cutting to harvest from the field. This hay is usually very rich, green, and soft. Most guinea pigs will devour this hay, but it may not wear the teeth down as well over time. Also, if your guinea pigs get used to eating 3rd cut hay all the time, they may become a little spoiled on that and refuse to eat other hay in the future.

Horse Quality Hay for Guinea Pigs

I use a 208 litre bin to store a 40lb bale of hay. Buying hay in bulk is a great way to save money with your guinea pigs!

Buying hay by the bale is a great option to save money with guinea pigs. If you buy your hay by the bale from a farmer, you may see hay labeled as “horse quality hay”.

This is a good thing, as horse-quality hay is typically higher quality. Cow-quality hay, for example, is usually lower-quality hay. This is best avoided for guinea pigs.

Horse-quality hay bales often consist of mixed types of hays. It’s important to find out what types of hay are in the bale so you can be sure that the mixture is suitable to feed your guinea pigs on a regular basis.

Are Mixed Bales of Hay Safe for Guinea Pigs?

When you buy hay by the bale, they are often labeled as mixed hay bales. This means there are a few different types of hay that make up one bale. Mixed bales can be perfectly fine for guinea pigs, but it’s important that you find out what types of hays are mixed in.

Oftentimes, these bales have alfalfa mixed in. Anything with alfalfa should really be avoided, as alfalfa can cause bladder stones in guinea pigs.

In Conclusion

Choosing the best hay depends on your guinea pigs and the kinds of hay you can find readily available in your area. Whatever you choose, make sure you provide unlimited access to hay so your guinea pig maintains a balanced diet and avoids health problems down the line.

Timothy and orchard grass hay are two of the best for daily feeding. Bluegrass, bermuda, brome, and sweet meadow hay are all great choices for everyday feeding as well.

Vitamin C is another crucial aspect of your guinea pig’s daily diet. To find a list of Vitamin C-rich foods you can feed your piggy, check out this article on the 17 Highest Vitamin C Foods for guinea pigs.

Poppy with an assortment of Vitamin C-rich bell peppers.

Similar Posts